Showing posts with label global warming. Show all posts
Showing posts with label global warming. Show all posts

20 February 2014

Just 15 More Years?

In mid-December 2013 a draft report by Working Group III of the UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change was leaked to the press. Here’s how the New York Times began its article on the report (emphasis added):
Nations have so dragged their feet in battling climate change that the situation has grown critical and the risk of severe economic disruption is rising, according to a draft United Nations report. Another 15 years of failure to limit carbon emissions could make the problem virtually impossible to solve with current technologies, experts found.
Climate change is a difficult concept to get people aroused about. Its dire consequences lie in the future, so it’s easy to think about it as something our children or grandchildren can take care of. But climate scientists worry that if we wait too long, we may reach a point of no return where no one will be able to take care of it.

What’s generally not understood is that the climate is changing more than we perceive. Burning fossil fuels and clearing forests emit carbon dioxide (CO2) that increases the thickness of the greenhouse gases (GHGs) blanketing the Earth and upset its energy balance by preventing it from radiating away all of the energy it absorbs as heat from the Sun. In accordance with the law of physics, the resulting imbalance increases Earth’s surface temperature and thereby the amount of heat it radiates away until radiated heat again matches absorbed heat.

But energy rebalancing is slow, principally because warming the ocean that contains 90 percent of Earth’s living space takes a long time. In the last century Earth’s temperature has increased about 1.3 degrees Fahrenheit. 
That’s an insignificant change when we relate it to our local temperature, but not when it represents the change in temperature of Earth’s entire surface — almost 200 million square miles, 70 percent of which is ocean — averaged across opposite seasons and day/night variations. And because of the thermal inertia of the ocean described above, the temperature will keep rising even if we immediately stop all new GHG emissions until the ocean catches up and the energy imbalance created by current GHG emissions has been eliminated.

Another inertial factor is the longevity of atmospheric CO2, which is more potent than all other GHGs combined in warming the planet. Unlike the other major long-term GHGs, which have chemical (and global warming) lifetimes from a decade or so (methane) to a century (nitrous oxide), CO2’s longevity is controlled by the Earth’s carbon cycle. Under current conditions, about half of an emission of CO2 is redistributed to the ocean, terrestrial biosphere and soil within a quarter century, but almost a fifth remains in the atmosphere to keep the planet warm for more than 500 years.

To forestall global overheating and “preserve a planet similar to that on which civilization developed and to which life on earth is adapted,” NASA climatologist James Hansen and other scientists concluded in 2008 that we need to reduce atmospheric CO2 concentration (trim the blanket) from what was then 385 ppm (parts per million molecules of air) and is now almost 400 ppm to a maximum of 350 ppm. How?

According to Hansen’s latest calculations, if we reduce fossil fuel emissions of GHGs by 6 percent a year beginning now, phase out deforestation and other land-use emissions in 2020-2030 and then reverse them — store atmospheric CO2 in the biosphere and soil  through reforestation and advanced land-use techniques — at twice the annual rate of current emissions, we can achieve 350 ppm by the end of the century (2100).

The timing is critical. What concerns climatologists are so-called “slow” feedbacks that gradually reinforce and aggravate global warming. Unlike “fast” feedbacks like the melting of the Arctic sea ice in summer that climatologists can observe and take into account, slow feedbacks are difficult to measure. Some that occurred during the ice ages of the last several thousand centuries like CO2 that the ocean emits when it’s warming are well known. Others like the breakup of the glacial ice sheets in Greenland and Antarctica and the release of vast methane deposits frozen beneath the permafrost, are more speculative since they haven’t occurred in millions of years. But given enough time to develop, slow feedbacks like these could run away with the climate and offset the benefit of eliminating GHG emissions.

Continuing business as usual and not starting the Hansen 6 percent annual cuts in fossil fuel emissions until 2020 would delay reaching the 350 ppm target until 2300 and give slow feedbacks two centuries (beyond 2100) to gather steam. Waiting until 2030 — just 15 more years — would give slow feedbacks four centuries.

If we want to avoid the risk that slow feedbacks will make climate stabilization impossible, our years of foot-dragging seem to be over. That is, we don't have 15 more years. Yet all Congress has to do is enact a gradually rising carbon tax or (better) a refundable revenue-neutral carbon fee to facilitate the replacement of fossil fuels with non-carbon fuels.

That’s as easy as convening the day after Pearl Harbor and declaring that a state of war existed, thereby allowing the U.S. to commit all the resources it needed to fight it. Call the state we’re in today whatever you want, it still represents an existential threat to the livelihood of everyone who comes after us that must be fought now.

03 December 2011

Peak Denial


When I was 11 or 12, I started worrying about what would happen if the world ran out of natural resources.  I can’t remember which I had in mind, but this was during World War II when availability of resources was talked about.  My father’s response was reassuring: we would invent some substitute, as we invented synthetic rubber during the war when natural rubber supplies were cut off.  Necessity is the mother of invention, as the phrase went.

I can imagine that I might have given my son the same answer -- but not my grandson.

One difference between now and when I was 11 or 12 is world population.  It was 2.4 billion then and 2.5 billion in 1950 when I entered college.  Today it’s seven billion, almost three times larger.

But in the same time period the world economy has grown almost ten times larger.  The Earth Policy Institute tells us that “consumption has begun to outstrip natural assets on a global scale."  Leaving aside non-regenerative assets like oil and fossil aquifers,

“demand has surpassed the earth’s regenerative capacity.  We are overharvesting forests, overplowing fields, overgrazing grasslands, overdrawing aquifers, overfishing oceans, and pumping far more carbon into the atmosphere than nature can absorb.”

Again leaving out oil, the demand for and growing scarcity of all important commodities in the last decade has led to a surge in prices that erased the benefits of a century of declining prices.  Investment guru Jeremy Grantham believes that rising prices are very probably here to stay, representing a “Paradigm Shift” that is “perhaps the most important economic event since the industrial Revolution.”
 
“We all need to develop resource plans,” he concludes, “particularly energy policies.  There is little time to waste.”

Tell  that to the US Congress, and what do you get?  Policies that encourage overplowing, overdrawing and the pumping of more carbon into the atmosphere than nature can absorb without warming the globe and acidifying its oceans.

By way of explanation (or excuse), Grantham suggests that humans are genetically ill-disposed to dealing with “long horizon issues and deferring gratification,” possibly because “we could not store food for over 99% of our species’ career and were totally concerned with staying alive this year and this week.”  He also thinks humans are “optimistic and overconfident,” traits which may have been important to our survival.  Especially Americans.

In Collapse: How Societies Choose to Fail or Succeed (Viking Penguin 2005), Jared Diamond’s examination of human societies that succumbed to environmental problems and others that survived them, the author said that in planning the book he assumed it would just be about environmental damage.  But later he realized he had to add other factors including the only one that proved significant in every society’s failure or success -- “the society’s responses to its environmental problems.” 

The environmental issues for these societies, chiefly deforestation and soil and water problems, were similar to those we face today.  Global warming, however, is a modern issue, derived from industrialization and the growth in human population that it made possible.  President Johnson was officially advised of it in 1965, but neither he nor any of his eight successors nor any Congress in the almost half-century since has taken action.

Global warming is a long horizon issue, of course, though not so distant that it won’t affect our grandchildren.  It also requires a global response involving other nations.  But we acted with other nations to control toxic chemicals (another modern environmental issue) creating a hole in the ozone layer.  The fault is not in our stars but in our politics.

Since fossil fuel emissions account for most of the increase in greenhouse gases that cause global warming, an obvious first response to reduce and eventually reverse this increase is to raise the price of fossil fuels by taxing them or capping their use, thereby making non-fossil energy more competitive.  But enough members of Congress are indebted to corporate interests that profit from fossil fuels or depend on them to block any such response.

Most of these members claim to doubt global warming.  But considering “the consensus scientific view” that global warming is occurring and that greenhouse gases emitted by human activities are the primary cause, their claim seems more like self-induced self-delusion -- a fig leaf we could call Peak Denial hiding their representation of the corporate interests held by the 1% rather than the interests of the 99% among their voters and the public good.

Global warming, left unchecked, will eventually create an environment that’s different from the one to which both we as a species and the food that we grow are genetically adapted.  How the world society responds to it may determine whether the society succeeds or fails.

Congress is consistently choosing to fail.  To make sure that society succeeds, we must choose a Congress that is not dependent on the 1%.